Comparisons
Comparisons
Email almost always offers two ways to do the same thing, and the debate over which is right rarely ends. We compare approaches, not services: how each works, what it gives you, where it gets in the way and who it suits. Choose the one that matches how you usually look for and keep emails.
A deleted email is usually needed most exactly when it can no longer be recovered, so archiving is almost always the safer choice.
How to read the tables: they describe general principles. Check your email settings to see whether you have folders, labels or an archive and what they are called.
Folders vs labels
| Criterion | Folders | Labels |
|---|---|---|
| How they work | An email sits in one folder, like a paper in a desk drawer | One email can carry several tags and can be found by any of them |
| Pros | Familiar and visual: you can see at once where everything is | An email can belong to both work and a trip without being duplicated |
| Cons | An email on two topics has to go into just one place | Without discipline, labels multiply and lose their meaning |
| Who it suits | People who like a simple structure and sort mail by hand | People who search a lot and are willing to keep a short list of labels |
Delete vs archive
| Criterion | Delete | Archive |
|---|---|---|
| What happens | The email goes to the bin and after a while disappears for good | The email leaves the inbox but stays in the mailbox and can be found by search |
| Pros | Frees up space and removes what you definitely won't need | A clean inbox, and what you need can be found even years later |
| Cons | Once the bin is emptied, the email usually can't be recovered | The archive takes up space, and heavy attachments gradually fill it |
| When to choose it | For spam, outdated notifications and emails with heavy files you have elsewhere | For messages from people, receipts, confirmations and anything that may come in handy |
One address vs several addresses
| Criterion | One address | Several addresses |
|---|---|---|
| How it works | Correspondence, shopping and sign-ups all go to one mailbox | Separate mailboxes for work, shopping, family or website sign-ups |
| Pros | Nothing to switch between: one password and one set of protections | Shop emails don't mix with personal ones, and a leak of one address affects the others less |
| Cons | Important emails drown among notifications, and the address quickly ends up on spam lists | You have to remember which address you used where and protect every mailbox |
| Who it suits | People who get few emails and rarely sign up on websites | People who shop online often, work with email every day or want to keep personal mail separate |
How to choose without endless debate
Ask yourself how you usually find an old email. If you remember where you put it, folders are closer to your style. If you type the sender's name or a couple of words from the subject into search, labels and the archive will suit you better, and you'll hardly need to file anything.
The same logic applies to addresses: a separate mailbox makes sense when the streams of email really are different. For shopping and sign-ups it takes the noise out of your personal mail, but every new address means another password and another second sign-in check you must not forget.
Read next
- Guides
Step-by-step advice: clear the inbox, unsubscribe from newsletters, write a clear email, set up an out-of-office reply and a signature. Plus the article catalogue.
- Tools
Password manager, two-factor authentication, a list of your addresses, reply templates, folders and labels, a backup of important emails.
- Problems
An email didn't arrive, wanted mail lands in spam, the mailbox is full, a forgotten password, an old email you can't find, mail meant for someone else.
- Glossary
Inbox, folder, label, filter, archive, spam, phishing, attachment, CC and BCC, two-factor authentication, in plain words.
- Questions
Answers about the guide, about keeping the inbox tidy and writing clear emails, and about keeping strangers out of your mailbox.
Sources
- Help sections of email services (in general terms)
- Account security recommendations (in general terms)
- Editorial material of this guide
The advice here is written in general terms and reflects how our editors saw the question when it was prepared. Mailboxes differ: menu items have different names, and some features simply don't exist everywhere. If your email service's help pages disagree with our advice, follow the help pages.